Innovation Magazine Summer 2024

Insight - 10/01/24

Creativity as a Natural Pathway

9 min

By Rebeccah Pailes-Friedman

Creativity as a Natural Pathway

This article, co-written by Rebeccah Pailes-Friedman and Elham Morshedzadeh, Ph.D., was published in the Summer 2024 Issue of Innovation Magazine.

As industrial designers, we often rely on the natural flow of creativity to fuel our work, drawing inspiration from our surroundings, cultural experiences, and intuitive processes. However, sticking exclusively to these familiar paths can sometimes limit our potential for truly groundbreaking innovation. In this discussion, five talented women industrial designers explore the concept of creativity as a natural pathway as well as the benefits of embracing less conventional approaches. By stepping out of our comfort zones and experimenting with new techniques, we can uncover disruptive solutions and push the boundaries of design, opening up a world of possibilities that may have otherwise remained hidden.

We began by defining natural versus unnatural paths to creativity. The discussion revealed diverse perspectives among the six of us. A natural path to creativity was generally seen as an organic process, drawing on intuition, personal experiences, and iterative design. Celeste Greenbaum, Human Centered Researcher and Industrial Designer at Philips, highlighted this by explaining that natural creativity stems from “things that you derive from your skill set from, or from iteration.” This type of creativity is intrinsic and emerges from the designer’s own abilities and observations, grounded in traditional and learned methods in the design process.

An unnatural or supernatural path to creativity, on the other hand, was thought to involve external influences or unconventional methods. For example, generating an algorithm or using AI was considered an unnatural pathway. An unnatural approach leverages technology and other external tools to stimulate creativity, pushing beyond the innate capabilities of a single human mind. Elham Morshedzadeh, Ph.D., Assistant Professor, University of Houston and IDSA WID Committee member, expanded on this by noting that unnatural creativity “can have a broader interpretation” and includes learned techniques that may not come intuitively. By embracing these unexpected and often abstract and not fully explored methods, designers can uncover innovative solutions that might not arise from traditional processes alone. As Dr. Mary Beth Privitera, M.Des., PhD FIDSA  Principal, Design & Human Factors at Sentiar and Professor, Biomedical Engineering University of Cincinnati, pointed out, the interplay between natural and supernatural pathways can lead to unique and diverse design outcomes, enriching the creative process through a dynamic exchange of ideas and methods.

The design process is fluid and knowing when to shift your thinking is critical. As the conversation shifted to pinpointing the moment when a designer realizes that it’s time to change up the way they are thinking, the group brought forth a rich tapestry of experiences and insights. Greenbaum reflected on challenges wherein traditional methods fell short, such as designing a product for children that initially seemed uncomfortable and unappealing. She shared, “I get really stuck when the design requirements lead to something that looks like a torture contraption.” Changing up the approach can lead to fresh ways to think about a design. This change often requires reaching outside conventional techniques and incorporating elements that transform the product into something playful and engaging. 

Privitera underscored the designer’s responsibility to think differently, stating, “It’s almost like your responsibility to think differently.” When assessing any project, it’s essential to ask ‘is this something that’s desirable?’ The drive to infuse unique, appealing elements into designs is necessary , whether developing medical tools or everyday kitchen items. By embracing diverse approaches, designers can break free from conventional constraints and create products that resonate on both functional and emotional levels.

Katie Lim, Senior Industrial Designer, frog & Chair of IDSA Women in Design NYC Chapter, emphasized the importance of storytelling in guiding clients and users through innovative changes, noting that “if you can tell somebody a really good story you can hook them in from the beginning.” Storytelling helps mitigate resistance to change and makes new ideas more accessible. It can be a valuable tool when faced with resistance to thinking differently. Morshedzadeh expanded on the significance of storytelling, particularly in today’s technologically advanced landscape. She pointed out that “having these technologies helps us to create more realistic stories” and has revolutionized how designers communicate their visions. This blend of narrative and visual tools fosters a deeper emotional connection between a product and its users.

The conversation then shifted to examining how natural and unnatural methods might influence user experience. This part of the discussion highlighted the importance of empathy, attention to detail, and the inherent biases that designers must navigate. Lim emphasized the significance of stepping outside of personal design perspectives to truly understand user needs, sharing an example of designing an unboxing experience for cancer patients. She noted that “going through the actual motions to understand all those in-between moments of the key touch points” is imperative for creating a user-centered experience. Greenbaum concurred, adding that meticulously mapping out every detail of user interaction is essential, even if it feels “unnatural” due to the depth of analysis required. 

A rigorous approach to understanding user experience ensures that designers can identify both the strengths and weaknesses of a design. On the other hand, Privitera highlighted the challenges of qualitative research, pointing out that it’s inherently biased by personal interpretations and selection criteria. She stressed that navigating these biases requires “taking that leap of faith and looking at it from another perspective” to achieve an optimal solution. She also described the complexity of designing for future technologies, such as augmented reality in medical applications, where traditional design tools and prototype testing fall short. Privitera aptly summarized this dynamic tension: “I’m designing a new future, but I’m not in that future. And so I’m predicting again what I think that future might be.” This underscores the iterative nature of design, where natural intuition and unnatural, innovative methods must work in tandem to enhance user experiences in the most effective way.

Balancing intuition and critical thinking in design, especially when using generative tools, was a topic that sparked diverse perspectives among the group. Yi-Ping Wong,  Director of Operations for IN2 INNOVATION believes that the balance lies in using generative tools for improvements, validations, and inspirations. “If we can feed generative tools with information and parameters derived from intuition and critical thinking, they can help generate ideas that we might not have thought of ourselves. While these ideas may not be the final solution, they can push the boundaries of our approach”  Greenbaum highlighted the importance of understanding both personal and stakeholder biases. She emphasized that designers must introduce innovations in ways that respect users’ autonomy and expertise.

Morshedzadeh echoed the need for designers to embrace scientific methods to enhance decision-making reliability, despite the resistance this approach might face within the design community. She argued that using established tested methods would help us avoid making biased decisions. This integration of scientific rigor can help designers navigate their preconceived notions and produce more robust outcomes.

Privitera discussed the fluid interplay between unstructured intuition and structured critical thinking. She illustrated this balance with a personal example: “In my own head, I am a superhero with the cape and I can come up with really creative ideas that are wacky and fun.” Yet, these ideas are then rigorously evaluated to ensure feasibility. This interplay is pivotal, as designers oscillate between unfettered creativity and practical constraints, depending on whether they are refining existing products or conceptualizing entirely novel ones. Starting with broad, imaginative concepts before refining them with practical constraints allows designers to avoid being constrained by existing paradigms. Lim noted, “If you start off with the constraints, you’re designing the same thing everyone else is designing.”  This process of shifting from unstructured to structured thinking fosters innovation while ensuring practical yet creative viability.

When discussing how to stay up to date with emerging technologies and tools in the design field using both natural and unnatural approaches, the panel offered a range of strategies. Lim emphasized the value of looking beyond the traditional design sphere: “I like to look outside of the design.” This approach broadens the scope of inspiration and keeps designers informed about trends in various industries.

Privitera highlighted the importance of attending conferences to gain exposure to unexpected innovations: “Attending conferences, you see a whole host of different things that you wouldn’t even expect.” She noted that events like the Industrial Designers Society of America (IDSA) conferences offer diverse insights that can inspire new design approaches. Industry conferences and tradeshows, such as CES (Consumer Electronics Show), and SXSW (South by Southwest), have always focused on the latest technologies, tools, and industry trends. These events provide an excellent opportunity to learn about a wide range of topics and perspectives in one setting. Wong added, “Networking with professionals who are passionate about these subjects is also valuable. Whether you agree or disagree on certain topics, it is important to maintain an open attitude towards discussion and new perspectives.”

Other participants also shared their methods for staying informed. Greenbaum mentioned the benefits of interdisciplinary learning that arose from her interest in cognitive psychology, which has now extended into nursing training to deepen her clinical knowledge. This point was emphasized by other panelists who shared examples of designers that sought additional training in fields like acupuncture and surgery. These experiences provide valuable perspectives that significantly enhance their design capabilities in their chosen field.

Morshedzadeh, sharing an academic perspective, emphasized the importance of continuous learning: “When I come across something that I believe I can teach or incorporate into one of our courses and it piques my interest, I’ll incorporate it into the curriculum, starting with elementary basics. This way, we can practice and explore its potential.” This approach not only keeps her skills sharp but also ensures that new graduates are well-equipped with the latest tools and technologies, boosting their confidence and employability.

In conclusion, the discussion among this group of industrial designers, all with a wide variety of experience and specialization,underscores the importance of embracing both natural and unnatural paths to creativity in the design process. While drawing from personal experiences and intuition forms the foundation of design, integrating unconventional methods and technologies can unlock new pathways of innovation. By challenging conventional thinking and experimenting with diverse approaches, designers can break free from limitations and uncover disruptive solutions that resonate deeply with users. Furthermore, maintaining a balance between intuitive creativity and critical analysis, as well as staying informed about emerging technologies through avenues like industry conferences and interdisciplinary learning, are essential for driving continuous growth and pushing the boundaries of design excellence. As we navigate the ever-evolving landscape of design, it is this dynamic interplay between tradition and innovation that fuels our journey towards creating impactful and meaningful experiences for users worldwide.

Looking for more design InsightsSign up for our newsletter and follow us on Instagram and LinkedIn for design news, multi-media recommendations, and to learn more about product design and development!


Related

Marcel Breuer Wassily Chair square

Insight - 10/28/24

Innovation and Expression: Why Designers Love Chairs So Much

6 min

Read More

Eileen Gray Bibendum Chair

Insight - 10/24/24

Design History Series N. 020

3 min

Read More

Male and female engineers in a lab

Insight - 09/23/24

Bridging the Gap: Strategies for Collaboration Between Designers and Engineers

8 min

Read More